Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
IndiaArchaeology · India Archaeology
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Show off your group to the world. Share a photo of your group with us.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Avestan and Vedic   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #4456 of 9415 |
Avestan and Vedic are obviously twin languages. Notice the similarity from Avesta to Sanskrit in the sample below:
 
tem amavantem yazatem
surem damohu seviytem
mithrem yazai zaothrabyo
'Mithra that strong mighty angel, most beneficent to all creatures, I will worship with libations'.
 
Becomes when rendered word for word in Sanskrit:
tam amavantam yajatam
yuram dhamasu yavistham
mitram yajai hotrabhyah
 
They may have a common root, somewhere. What is generally considered to be that common language? Does it exist in traces or has it become an isolate?
 
It is well known that the 'S' in Vedic is transferred as 'H' in Avestan. Examples:
Asura > Ahura
Saraswati > Harahwati
etc, etc
 
It would seem to me, that the conversion from S to H is more of a logical directional transfer than from H to S, because, 'Sah' to 'Ha' is easily followed, than v.v.
 
If that be the case, will it not be logical to assume that their 'parent' language may have been more akin to Vedic than Avestan; in other words, is Avestan later than Vedic?
 
Any thoughts on this from the experts?
 
Ram

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com

Mon Jan 8, 2007 5:49 pm

varmha
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #4456 of 9415 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Avestan and Vedic are obviously twin languages. Notice the similarity from Avesta to Sanskrit in the sample below: tem amavantem yazatem surem damohu seviytem ...
Ram Varmha
varmha
Offline Send Email
Jan 8, 2007
6:25 pm

... creatures, I will worship with libations'. ... This is "trick" linguistics, used often to "prove" languages are related. If the sample given above could be...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 8, 2007
10:51 pm

Attached below is a link to Avestan dictionary. Even those with a nodding acquaintance with Vedic/Sanskrit can find a significant list of word-cognates between...
Ram Varmha
varmha
Offline Send Email
Jan 9, 2007
8:26 pm

... nodding acquaintance with Vedic/Sanskrit can find a significant list of word-cognates between Avesta and Vedic/ Sanskrit; some words being exactly the same...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 9, 2007
11:16 pm

What are the basic grammatical differences between Avesta and Vedic? The best one I could find on the web is the following: ...
Ram Varmha
varmha
Offline Send Email
Jan 11, 2007
8:14 pm

... For info on Old Avestan: http://www.utexas.edu/cola/centers/lrc/eieol/aveol-TC-R.html Regards, Paul Kekai Manansala Quests of the Dragon and Bird Clan ...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 12, 2007
6:32 am

Here is an "old" text on Avesta grammar and comparison with Sanskrit. http://www.avesta.org/kanga/grammar_opf_files/ Ram ... For info on Old Avestan: ...
Ram Varmha
varmha
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2007
11:39 pm

Not entirely on topic, but in some parts of Rajasthan (limited to what I know of), replacing S with H is prevalent even today! -- jaju...
Ravindra Jaju
ravindrajaju
Offline Send Email
Jan 9, 2007
8:26 pm

I have noticed this in assamese also. I dont know if its possible to designate vedic as being older than avestan based on one trait. vedic may prserve some...
munnubanerjee
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2007
11:43 pm

... There are quite a few IE-ists who claim that the center is more innovative than the periphery. You will find such claims in the cybalist (on Yahoo groups)....
raonath
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2007
1:56 am

Similarly, Mittani Indo-Aryan language is considered older than Vedic or Avestan because it has aika instead of eka. Vedic is supposed to have merged 'ai' to...
ayachitman
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2007
5:18 am

... Seems like a pretty standard approach in proving one's point in such (may I call it) speculative science fields. Unlike pure sciences, deviations can be...
Ravindra Jaju
ravindrajaju
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2007
7:27 pm

... That vowel merger is an the gypsey language behaves in an opposite manner) which is itself based on another dubious theory of reconstructing laryngeals...
mkelkar2003
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2007
7:27 pm

... My belief based on discussion on the old ANE list is that no Mitanni or Near East specialists believe in 'Mitanni Aryan' anymore. It's mainly...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2007
7:31 pm

Minor mittani aryan presence among majority hurrian speaking must have been blown out of proportion by IEists. But that does not mean we have to swing the oher...
munnubanerjee
Offline Send Email
Jan 17, 2007
3:47 am

... I don't agree. There never was really any argument for an "Aryan" presence in Mitanni. The linguistic evidence was always very weak, but the conjecture...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 18, 2007
12:43 am

... The linguistic evidence for Mitanni Indo-Aryan -- i.e., an Old Indo- Aryan language spoken by a section, no matter how small that was, of the population of...
Francesco Brighenti
frabrig
Offline Send Email
Jan 19, 2007
6:38 am

... This is not a "conjecture" -- check ... Indeed it is only conjecture. The Mitanni literature itself makes no mention of "Aryans" and as I've stated,...
Paul Kekai Manansala
pinatubo.geo
Offline Send Email
Jan 19, 2007
7:31 pm

... I do not know what "widely accepted scholarly paradigm" is being referred to here. Horses were introduced to the near east by Hurrians not the Mittani and...
mkelkar2003
Offline Send Email
Jan 21, 2007
12:24 am

... Did I hold that Indo-Aryan speakers living in the Kingdom of Mitanni *introduced* horses in Syria/N. Mesopotamia? I confined myself to saying that "there...
Francesco Brighenti
frabrig
Offline Send Email
Jan 22, 2007
1:06 am

... Speaking of Mittani "Indo-Aryans": They have closer connection with Pakistan/India than to a presumed non demonstrable connection with Central Asia. Check...
mkelkar2003
Offline Send Email
Jan 23, 2007
5:08 am

... The connection of the Mitanni-IA linguistic element with Central Asia (more exactly, with the BMAC area in the centuries after the decline of that culture...
Francesco Brighenti
frabrig
Offline Send Email
Jan 23, 2007
6:40 pm

... That is exactly what I mean. It is a *presumed* relation based on linguistic reconstrcution and a hypothetical group of "Indo-Iranians" that no one can...
mkelkar2003
Offline Send Email
Jan 24, 2007
9:55 pm

... "Mitanni Indo-Aryans' expertise as charioteers and horse trainers ... You are holding that Mitanni "Indo-Aryans' expertise as charioteers was no doubt...
mkelkar2003
Offline Send Email
Jan 23, 2007
5:09 am

Commenting on some discussion on the time frame of RV and Avesta, Rajesh Kochchar writes http://acorn.nationalinterest.in/?p=2249#comment-94190 While...
JK
tiptronicus
Online Now Send Email
Jan 24, 2007
10:04 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help