I've noticed recently that a number of feeds I follow have not been working properly in that my aggregator doesn't generate a hyperlink to the entry. I took a...
... Unfortunately, reversing these aspect: - "ok, if the <link> has been moved to <guid>, then I should surround my <title> with the <guid> link, right?" isn't...
If they're missing the link tag that's one thing. The guid element is not a replacement for it. What a guid element IS, well, that's an entirely other ...
... Actually, if they are valid RSS 2.0 feeds, then either the <guid> is a permalink, or it is <guid isPermaLink="false"> - somehow I missed this every time...
... Could you make it turned on by default, duplicating the data in <guid>? People who've been using Radio Userland for a long time often don't recheck to see...
... Ah, I missed that as well (again). What's the design decision for Radio, then? Before <guid> and RSS 2.0, how was Radio handling <link>'s? Was it throwing...
... This is /really/ going to be a bad idea. Being "stingy" and having a guid as the link and 'saving' the link is going to cause a lot of tools that look for...
... having a guid as ... that look for ... That is not what isPermaLink is for. Also Radio Userland doesn't behave that way. It's an option to have link and...
... It is a problem if reader programs, previously used to working, suddenly start failing when discovering that elements have gone missing. The whole "link is...
... AFAIK no elements have gone missing. I think Tim is wrong. Radio Userland's RSS files have never had link elements, unless you enabled this option. The...
Just curious, what aggregator do you use?? ... From: tappnel To: RSS2-Support@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, November 01, 2002 7:28 AM Subject: [RSS2-Support]...
Sjoerd that's correct. No elements have gone missing. ... From: Sjoerd Visscher To: RSS2-Support@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, November 01, 2002 9:53 AM ...
I tried with AmphetaDesk, blagg and even did a test with the MovableType RSSFeed plugin -- not an aggregator, but close. ... properly in my aggregator....
... Arguing the point doesn't change the fact that some tools when pulling RSS *expect* the link element to be present. Tim expressed concern that feeds ...
No Dave, that's arguably incorrect. But I hold no optimism on having a rational discussion of it. Feeds previously known to use the link tag have stopped...
Nope, a recent server timestamp issue deleted many back copies of data. Thus pulling pre-2.0 feeds can't be provided at this time. I suppose it'd be possible...
... Maybe there's a bug in Radio, but there's certainly not a design change in Radio. My feed is generated by Radio and had link elements in RSS 0.94, and...
Okay, please let me know if you have a bug to report. Dave ... From: Bill Kearney To: RSS2-Support@yahoogroups.com Sent: Friday, November 01, 2002 3:58 PM ...
Sjoerd, a few bits of data: 1. When Radio 8 shipped in January, it didn't support item-level <title> or <link> elements for <item>s. 2. In March we added...
... Tim, if it's any consolation, I could probably write you two or three lines of code to get <guid isPermaLink> working as a <link> replacement in your ...
... For the sake of interoperability, for the sake of the thousands of little scripts out there that look for <item><title><description><link>, and for the...
... I agree. I can't imagine any problems if Radio would output a link element with the permalink where it previously wouldn't have generated a link element. ...
Hi, I was wondering (tell me if i totally miss something) : All the feeds seem to have 15 or more items. This means that if a Weblogger posts one new item, his...
... New items to whom? If someone posts only one item, then the other 14 items are "old" and thus removed, creating a feed of only one new item. The next time...
The trouble, of course, is telling who got the old items. Partial delivery of XML fragments is one possiblity but there's nothing that supports it. Using...