Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
TechRhet · TechRhet is devoted to exploring tech teaching, learning, communication, and community.
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want your group to be featured on the Yahoo! Groups website? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Turnitin.com   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #6849 of 6862 |
Re: [TechRhet] Turnitin.com

Let me say up front, Iıve never used this service. An article in the May
17, 2002, issue of The Chronicle of Higher Education (Andrea L. Foster,
³Plagiarism Detection Tool Creates Legal Quandary²) indicates that there
some potential legal/ethical issues with the service. Hereıs an excerpt:

Lawyers say the problem with Turnitin.com is that student papers are copied
in their entirety to the services' database, which is a potential
infringement of students' copyrights. (An author doesn't need to file for a
copyright; the law automatically bestows on authors the rights to their
written works.) And the copying is sometimes done without students'
knowledge or consent, which is a potential invasion of their privacy.

Those concerns contributed to the decision by officials at the University of
California at Berkeley not to subscribe to Turnitin.com, says Mike R. Smith,
assistant chancellor for legal affairs: "We take student
intellectual-property rights seriously, and that became one of the trouble
spots for us in moving ahead with this proposal."

Dan
___________
Dan Butcher
Instructor and Webmaster, Dept. of English
University of Alabama at Birmingham
HB207D, 205/934-8578
dbutcher@...
http://www.uab.edu/english/




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]




Mon Nov 25, 2002 5:35 pm

uabenglish
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #6849 of 6862 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Colleagues: I dutifully filed many messages about plagiarism on our list over the past two years and forwarded them to our assistant dean, who was very ...
Edward J. Gallagher
ejg1@...
Send Email
Nov 22, 2002
4:48 pm

In a message dated 11/22/02 10:49:29 AM Central Standard Time, ... Roger writes>>Ed. We have a horrid problem with plagiarism here as well. My solution is to...
RogerREasson@...
Send Email
Nov 22, 2002
5:15 pm

I think Roger's right about tailoring assignments so that plagiarism is impossible -- in composition courses where the teacher has a chance to see essays in...
Margaret M. Barber
barber@...
Send Email
Nov 22, 2002
7:29 pm

Using a computer class for at least part of the course is a possibility: for research papers, I have students bring in their notes and outlines, already...
Carolyn Birden
cmcb007
Offline Send Email
Nov 22, 2002
10:30 pm

I also believe strongly in the value of tailoring research assignments and working individually with students as well as in class to help students learn the...
Kilborn, Judith M.
kilbornj
Offline Send Email
Nov 23, 2002
4:05 pm

I don't know what I'm doing wrong or right, but honestly, I can't recall a single instance in my teaching in which I've caught someone with the proverbial red...
Steve Krause
Steven_D_Krause
Offline Send Email
Nov 24, 2002
2:50 pm

... Actually, in a sentence that you cut, Judy says that both students admitted that they plagiarized, one because of not having the time and the other because...
Tari Fanderclai
tfanderclai
Offline Send Email
Nov 24, 2002
3:47 pm

... Oops-- my bad, you're right. ... Well, three quick thoughts: * I didn't jump into this thread until this morning, so I'm not one of those folks you're...
Steve Krause
Steven_D_Krause
Offline Send Email
Nov 25, 2002
2:33 am

Steve, the case of the student getting her paper from nine sources was a case of plagiarism, pure and simple. She knew what she needed to do to use her sources...
Kilborn, Judith M.
kilbornj
Offline Send Email
Nov 24, 2002
10:48 pm

Thank you, Tari, for putting your finger on exactly what it is about this discussion is scary to me. I wish that I'd read your response before I'd posted mine,...
Kilborn, Judith M.
kilbornj
Offline Send Email
Nov 24, 2002
11:02 pm

Oops. I meant to save and hit send instead. My unfinished sentence below -- "And to be honest, I'm glad t" -- should have been a few sentences: "And to be...
Kilborn, Judith M.
kilbornj
Offline Send Email
Nov 24, 2002
11:16 pm

... Like I said in the message I just sent, I don't mean to imply that I have the answers to this by any stretch of the imagination. All we can really do in...
Steve Krause
Steven_D_Krause
Offline Send Email
Nov 25, 2002
12:16 am

Steve is right in that turnitin gives some false positives. For instance, if a student types a space between her quote mark and the quoted text, that text will...
Kilborn, Judith M.
kilbornj
Offline Send Email
Nov 25, 2002
3:05 pm

Let me say up front, Iıve never used this service. An article in the May 17, 2002, issue of The Chronicle of Higher Education (Andrea L. Foster, ³Plagiarism...
Dan Butcher
uabenglish
Offline Send Email
Nov 25, 2002
5:35 pm

On Mon, 25 Nov 2002, Dan Butcher wrote: Chronicle article Dan mentions: http://chronicle.com/free/v48/i36/36a03701.htm ... This is true of other detection...
The Teach
ababion
Offline Send Email
Nov 25, 2002
6:06 pm
Advanced

Copyright İ 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help