Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
cybalist
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want your group to be featured on the Yahoo! Groups website? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Re: [tied] Laryngeal theory as an unnatural   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #25176 of 65407 |
Re: [tied] Re: Crows and Garlands

19-08-03 16:03, Daniel J. Milton wrote:

> --- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, "Richard Wordingham" > > > >
> Latin corvus 'crow' ....... I can't find this little group in
> Torsten's k-r- words! They are related by the curve of a corvid's
> beak. Latin _corvus_ also means some type of hook.
> Richard.
> ********
> Are you suggesting a derivation of 'corvus' from the *ker root,
> based on the (not very prominent) hook of a raven's beak? Isn't it
> more probable (and generally accepted) that the bird name is
> onomatopoeic, and that the use for grabbing tools is a secondary
> application in Latin?

The raven is just about the only corvid with a hooked beak. Rooks and
crows have large but only slightly curved beaks -- nothing conspicuous.
All of them go "kraa kraa", however. I met (and heard) a small flight of
ravens just two ours ago, and I agree with Daniel that the name is more
likely onomatopoeic.

Piotr




Tue Aug 19, 2003 5:24 pm

caraculiambro
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #25176 of 65407 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

... Latin corvus 'crow' ....... I can't find this little group in Torsten's k-r- words! They are related by the curve of a corvid's beak. Latin _corvus_ also...
Daniel J. Milton
danjmi
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
2:03 pm

... The raven is just about the only corvid with a hooked beak. Rooks and crows have large but only slightly curved beaks -- nothing conspicuous. All of them...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
5:24 pm

... and which is the verb for the onomatopeea the raven makes? Every language must ( I guess ) have a verb for this special sound make by crows and raves. In...
alex
altamix
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
6:18 pm

... E.g. Polish <kruk> 'raven', <krakac'> 'croak (like a raven)'. English <croak> is of course onomatopoeic itself. Piotr...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
6:26 pm

... by ... English ... ************ I will add here Alb. <krrok> 'to caw, to crow', suffixed form <krrokat> 'id.', n. krrokamë 'caw', all of onomatopoeic...
Abdullah Konushevci
a_konushevci
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
7:54 pm

... There is also "a cârâi", which I guess is used mostly for crows and I think it comes directly from the onomatopea "crrr". Moshu -- Homepage:...
Mihai Batranu
mauchout
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
7:53 am

... corvid's ... root, ... it ... and ... conspicuous. ... Whence English etc. 'crow' and Germanic *xro:kaz > English 'rook', and I have vague recollection of...
Richard Wordingham
richardwordi...
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
6:27 pm

... The 'horn, antler, head' etymon is definitely different from the corvid set, and involves *k^, not *k; more precisely, it's *k^r.-n- or *k^er-h2-, with...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
7:09 pm

... _curvare_ 'curve, ... between ... corvid ... large ... *k-? Pokorny (root #919) has a nice set of 'magpie' words, e.g. Sanskrit _sa:rika:_ 'Indian magpie'...
Richard Wordingham
richardwordi...
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
8:03 pm

... Discussed last April; see: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/cybalist/message/20975 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/cybalist/message/20980 ...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
10:26 pm

On Wed, 20 Aug 2003 00:25:54 +0200, Piotr Gasiorowski ... On the subject of ornithology (off topic): since a couple of years, the city where I live (Hilversum,...
Miguel Carrasquer
mcvwxsnl
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
11:31 pm

... the ... over by ... any ... Veneres ... sparrows) have ... wide- ... Just Magpies in Manchester, but the Crows are terrible in Moscow, although their...
Ben McGarr
celteuskara
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
5:05 am

... They are certainly rooks. Rooks are colonial and like to claim city parks as their rookeries. Ravens, which are much bigger and to a lesser extent...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
6:43 am

... Ravens used to be rare in the eastern U.S. outside of wilderness areas of the north (Maine, New Hampshire, the Adirondack mountains of upstate New...
Jim Rader
jrader01060
Offline Send Email
Aug 25, 2003
6:13 pm

... I hadn't seen those. ... also ... initial ... likely than ... like 'magpie' > ... and the Greek 'raven' _korax_. Can we not also include Latin corvus,...
Richard Wordingham
richardwordi...
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
12:09 am

... It's hard to be sure about anything here, especially in view of all that possible onomatopoeic reshaping. I've always thought of <corvus> as somehow...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
6:14 am

... wo- ... that ... names ... The reason I left out Words for "raven" in http://www.angelfire.com/rant/tgpedersen/krn.html ...
tgpedersen
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
9:52 am

At 5:52:19 AM on Wednesday, August 20, 2003, tgpedersen ... Old word. According to SAOB the Swedish word is from OSw <korper>; ON has <korpr>. According to...
Brian M. Scott
bmscotttg
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
10:08 am

... Hence also Finnish <korppi> (Korppi huus: "Ei milloinkaan"). To be sure, the final /-i/ betrays a relatively recent loan. Piotr...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
11:59 am

... sure, ... E.A. Poe in Finnish? What next? Even though 'raven' is a loan from Swedish, 'crow' seems to be in most FU languages. Hung. - varja' Finnish -...
Peter P
peteput
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
3:35 am

... varjú ['vOr-ju:] "crow;" holló ['hol-lo:] "raven" ... Hungarian szarka ['sOr-kO], Rumanian tzarca ['tzar-k&], assumed to be a loan from Hungarian (Spread...
tolgs001
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
10:12 am

... ************ I am afraid that Hungarian <szarka> and Romanian <tzarka> are derived from Slavic _šarka_ 'colored bird' (cf. šara 'spot' with big family of...
Abdullah Konushevci
a_konushevci
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
10:59 am

... But Slavic has (*s(v)arka: >) *s(v)orka, becoming <soroka> ~ <s(v)raka> ~ <sroka> in the modern languages. This word is a far more likely, not to say...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
12:26 pm

... Isn't this just an attempt to portray the bird's call? The two sites in my last post give the Old English name as - "Ceo ... [or] ... Ceahhe" not too...
Ben McGarr
celteuskara
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
10:35 pm

... be ... from ... ************ If it could be of any help, in Altaic languages the word for <magpie> is _saqsaqan_ (Turkish "saksaGan"), probably...
Abdullah Konushevci
a_konushevci
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
10:38 am

... I was amused by the definitely un-corvine sound of "Nevermore" in the Finnish translation. If that's any comfort, most Polish translations of "The Raven"...
Piotr Gasiorowski
caraculiambro
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
12:16 pm

... the ... translations of ... It's not without some merit. "Korppi huus: ei milloinkaan". "Huus" would often be written "huusi" in prose. The /i/ is 3rd...
Peter P
peteput
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2003
7:48 pm

... Isn't ... secondary ... is ... two ... ************ I believe that also Alb. <qep> 'beak', prefixed form <sqep> 'beak; bill', singularized plural <qip>...
Abdullah Konushevci
a_konushevci
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
7:35 pm

... hmmm there is the same semantism for the root "cor-" coroi= name for several small predatory birds like the falcons( cf DEX, "coroi" < Hungarian "karvaly")...
alex
altamix
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2003
6:51 pm

... why should be a magpie associated with the crow or raven? Just because they are birds? Their noise does not sound simmilar and they are not looking alike....
alex
altamix
Offline Send Email
Aug 20, 2003
4:29 am
 First  |  |  Next > Last 
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help