Greetings, I've been sitting at my computer much of this evening working on the paper I'll present at the Stanford Online Deliberation Conference in mid-May...
I'm not sure how you are operationalizing deliberation, but we did a study of idea generation that seems to share your methodological approach. Our approach ...
Michele H Jackson
jackson@...
Apr 14, 2005 3:11 am
12
Thanks for this suggestion. I have HCR on my shelf at work (sometimes those mailed journals come in handy). I'm operationalizing deliberation as having the...
Dear Jenny (I address this message to everyone assuming that the discussion might be of general interest), I think that the question of how to operationalize...
... This seems to be a very important question. I sense that many (online) deliberative experiments are too detached from real world political processes. On...
Hi Steve and Jens, Thanks for your thoughts here. I'm thinking of "good" in the sense of good for democracy and good for the people talking politics in helping...
Jenny, I've thought for a long time that the gold standard for real world deliberation among the general population is the jury room. If you agree that that's...
Todd Davies
tdavies@...
Apr 15, 2005 6:38 am
17
Steven asks whether good (online-) deliberation is actually just a nice process and whether it's really worth the effort to strive for good deliberation, at...
Hi Jenny, Steve, Jens and other deliberation researchers, We are trying to take a somewhat different approach, which involves working closely with existing...
There are some works detailing the necessary elements of "good" deliberation: * Burkhalter, Stephanie, John Gastil, and Todd Kershaw. 2002. "A Conceptual...
Thanks for the citations and the observations. Very helpful. It strikes me, though, that one of the sticky problems with the "deliberation" literature is the...
hi, just a notice on a "dicovery" I just made: the following newly established scientific online-journal with free access in accordance with the open access...
Folks at E-Democracy.Org would like your input on how to hardwire deliberative elements into the new open source GroupServer platform. This is the first time...
The following is a repost a comment I made on the Deliberation 2005 conference Blog. Beyond the logistical benefits of technology that enables online ...
Dear deliberation researchers: This is my first message to this list. Thank you all for contributing a lot of interesting ideas on “deliberation.” I’ve...
Immediacy and the clarification of intent in exchanges in online deliberation are particularly important. I have just issued a public draft of an XML schema...
Well, I've just returned from a terrific weekend at Stanford. The Second Online Deliberation Conference was one of the best conferences I've attended. Bringing...
I'd like to echo Jenny's sentiments and especially the kudos and thanks to Todd. --On Tuesday, May 24, 2005 5:50 PM +0000 Jenny Stromer-Galley ... Peter M....
A lot depends on the environment in which the deliberation took place, what the risk / reward psychology is, who the participants are, who the moderators are,...
I have asked for input on formal structures of deliberation. Please see: http://www.online-deliberation.net/conf2005/blog/?p=678 Sincerely, Steven -- Dr....
With application in my memeio project in mind I offer the following formalized view and generalization of deliberation for comments. Deliberation is the formal...
Well, for another view, making an analogy with mediation processes, take at look at http://www.qub.ac.uk/mgt/papers/prefer/latrobe.html, in particular...
David R. Newman
d.r.newman@...
May 27, 2005 5:42 pm
32
Dear Dr. Newman, That is excellent and interesting resource and, of course, informal dialog precedes the creation of more formal documents. As a computer...
I should also note that I do not discount or ignore the ongoing informal dialog that occurs at the periphery or in the iunderground of a deliberation. However,...
Dear all, I am now mid-way through my first year of a PhD programme in the department of sociology, university of surrey. A brief outline of my research is...
Hi Kerill Don't know what you know, so hope I'm not being too obvious...but the project most like yours is UK local Issues Forum: http://e-democracy.org/uk/ ...
Smith, Ella
E.Smith@...
Jun 7, 2005 8:31 am
36
Thanks for that Ella, I am aware of the E-Democracy. org work, ill have a look at the teledemocracy projects and get back to you. I was also unware of the...
Hi Jenny, my name is Mr. Kerill Dunne and I am new to this forum - I have emailed an intro form to this forum last week. Can you let me know where i might get...
There are lots of coding systems depending what you want to measure. Some years ago I devised a coding system to measure elements of critical and uncritical...
David R. Newman
d.r.newman@...
Jun 7, 2005 7:22 pm
39
Hello Wu Mei, I think your questions are very interesting and it would be great to find out more about your research project (content analysis of online ...