Hi Peter and All,
--- Peter VanDerWal <
evdl@...> wrote:
> >> > If the car can run on as little a 600 wh/mile
> at
> >> 60 mph (can any
> >> > currently available EV actually run that
> >> efficiently over the long
> >> > term in traffic and dealing with elevations?),
> >> you're looking at a
> >> > power requirement of 36kw.
> >>
> >> Umm, that's a tad high, I'd say 15-20 kwh is more
> >
> > You think!!
> >
> >
> >> accurate for typical
> >> EVs. Jerry will probably disagree (and insist
> it's
> >> much lower) but he
> >> tends to be wildly optimistic.
> >
> > Of course I disagree, what would you expect
> ;-))
> > But my disgreements are based on facts. My
> > E woody gets MOL 100wthrs/mile from the plug at
> 45mph
>
> 45mph average or top speed? Anyway, we are talking
At the moment, top speed is 45mph as I had to cut
back to 36vdc battery pack as the VW front end could
not handle the extra weight and why I never fixed it
completely up.
But at 48vdc it did 60 mph on a 3.5hp 36vdc 100amp
GE citi-car motor. I was probably getting 7hp out of
it at the time by overloading it. Voltage sag was
large as I was using old 12vdc Dynasty Gel batts and
6gge wire. 40vdc and 150 amps at the motor/6kw.
So that's another proof I can do what I say with
the Freedom EV which should have 1/3 less drag than
the E woody easily.
> about 60 mph. Power
> (and energy required) go up as the square of the
> speed. So even your
> e-woody would take roughly twice that at 60 mph,
> which works out to around
> 10kw/hour. I'd suspect it might even take a bit
> more than that. Hook up
Didn't prove out that way. See above. But the
45mph was from the plug and the 60 mph was from the
motor terminals close where the gen would be hooked to
thru the controller which is 95% eff?.
> an E-meter and check how much power it draws at
> 60mph on flat ground
> without wind and let us know.
Amp/volt meter 2 ways twice without wind on a flat
Fla road. 6kw or about 7hp on the overloaded motor.
Just what EV of America spreadsheet predicted.
>
> > So I expect that my new optimized composite
> > Freedom EV with a CD of about .24, low resistance
> > tires, PWM controller, 1,300lb, 2 more eff motors
> > series/parallel with a higher gear ratio to do
> about
> > 100wthr/mile at 60mph which isn't that hard as you
> are
> > going 33% more miles.
>
> Color me skeptical, I'll believe it when I see it.
No problem, in a few months it will be ready.
>
> > Also I'm not the only person getting this low
> > power level as John Bryan? gets the same in his VW
> > Ghia at a fair more weight, slightly worse aero
> though
> > slightly lower frontal area.
>
> Looking at your prototype and John's Ghia, I'll bet
> you $100 that HE has
> the lower total drag.
I'd hate to take your money as I've proved it with
the much higher drag E woody. Come down and test one
when you get back.
Not only does the Ghia look
> like it has a smaller
> frontal area,
I said it did.
but I also think it's has a lower Cd.
Not hardly!! You as many just don't understand
aerodynamics it seems. Go read some airplane drag
studies amoung other sources. For instance the middle,
rear, wheelwells are much more important than the
front!!!
While the Ghia is better than many cars, that's
not saying much.
If you look closely at the EV1, the Honda Insight
and the Selectria Sunrise, you will see much more of
the Freedom EV in it than the Ghia or any other car.
They all have Kammbacks, wheelwell treatments, low
parasitic drag and smooth bottoms.
> I'll grant you that your fiberglass body looks like
> it has a lower Cd than
> the E-woody, but I think your .24 figure is more
> than a little optimistic.
My success in very fast sailboats going to windward
says differently. Aerodynamics does not follow what
most people think is aero. Use yarn and smoke and you
can find a lot of interesting things.
>
> > For your bloated EV conversions, then yes,
> you
> > will need more as I've always said, about
> > 5-7kw/1,000lbs of EV depending on it's eff.
>
> I agree that lighter more aero EVs are defintely
> desireable (and doable).
And cheaper, more eff, cost effective.
>
> And you are definitely winning kudos for
> lightweight. I just don't buy
> your guestimates on Cd, but it looks like you are
> getting closer to
> proving it one way or the other.
Yes, we'll see soon. But as I've already done most
of this with the E woody, I'm not worried. I could be
30% off and still beat the pants off of everything
else out there including the EV1 in total drag!!
But unless I could really do something a lot
better, I just leave it to the drones that are happy
with a 1% improvement. I like to go for leaps, not
baby steps. Though that seems to bother many people.
But they have always said I can't do things I do. I'm
use to it now.
>
> >>
> >> My pickup (far from efficient) uses approx 15kw
> at
> >> 60 mph on flat ground.
> >> Figure a bit more in the hills (lots more going
> up,
> >> zero kw coming down,
> >
> > MOL even's out.
>
> Not quite, you loose more energy going up than you
> can regain going down,
> simple physics (mm, 2nd law of thermodynamics?)
I agree and what I meant.
>
> >
> >> possibly regen if your vehicle has it). A
> >> reasonably efficient, full size
> >> EV could easily average 15-20 kw/h at 60 mph.
> >
> > An overweight lead mine maybe!!
>
> Well I did say "full size" and "easily". Besides
> extrapolations on the
> data you've presented for your e-woody indicate that
> it's not that much
> better at 60mph.
Except at 1/3 or so the power needed in the
Freedom EV!!! ;-))
> The vast majority of people in the US will NOT build
> their own vehicle and
> even fewer would be willing to build/drive something
> like the E-woody.
That's why I'm going into production as they want
them but no one will build them for sale. Which is
fine for me as I don't like direct competition.
Beating each other to death over a nickle is for bean
counters. I go for the big bucks. ;-))
> >
> > Since you easily get 11-12kw from a gal of gas
> in
> > a DC gen and I get 100wthrs/mile, then what would
> be
> > optimistic?
>
> At 45 mph! We are talking about highway speeds here
> Jerry. What does it
> draw at 60 mph? At 75?
I have only taken the E woody to 60mph so you'll
just have to be satisfied with that for now. And at
6kw to do 60mph, then that is 100wthrs/mile. That's
also the first time I calculated it at 60mph as I
never go that fast anymore in thr E woody, just did it
a couple times as the range with 4 12v gel cells was
short. But I had figured so.
>
> >
> > Great idea, do you have $45k+?
>
> Actually yes, I have that much sitting in my
> checking account right now.
> Not going to spend it on a prius though.
Don't blame you as what an EV you could build for
1/2-1/3 of that!!
>
> > My goal is to bring an affordable EV most
> > everyone can afford, maintain with 70-100 mile
> range,
> > 80mph for $13k with unlimited hybrid range as an
> > option. I don't see any of you doing it. Why?
> Scared?
>
> Jerry, if you actually bring one to market at that
> price, I might just buy
> one.
You and many others. I'll only sell to EV'ers for
the first 20 or so as I need people who know what they
are doing for good feedback, improvements before
turning them loose to the public.
>
> > If you were really into EV's, you would give
> > solutions instead of just saying it can't be done,
> > putting it down. Why don't you be part of the
> solution
> > instead of being the problem?
>
> I just don't think being overly optimistic is a good
> way to solve this
> problem. I think being realistic is a better way to
> build a bussiness for
> the long term.
I believe I'm being realistic within my knowledge
base I'm very comfortable with my projections. I've
been mulling this over for 10 yrs so it's not like I
haven't though about it a lot.
> This time next year I'll have enough money saved up
Those bonuses are nice, arn't they!! I'd never be
able to survive as your bosses and I could never get
along. I think way outside the box! Hell, I can't even
see the box most of the time ;-))
> that I won't have to
> work for a while and can devote a couple years to
> doing nothing but
> working on my ideas. That's when I'll start
After an unpleasant experience with our gov I
decided to do that 30 yrs ago and been playing with
stuff ever since. It's a great life but hard for many
to do as no structure at all and that drives many
crazy. But I love it and has allowed me to do many
things others have only dreamed of.
> building my hybrid.
> If yours works out, I'll definitely be picking your
> brains for ideas.
> Especially on molds and so forth.
As always, be glad to help.
Better go out and see what the hurricane's blown
away. It did in my 10' high prized Elephant Ear plant
earlier!! But I can prop it back up and it will grow
back upright. Luckily we are only on the fringe of it.
The poor people in the panhandle will get the worst of
it. Ah, life in paradise!!
Thanks,
Jerry Dycus
>
> Cheers, and good luck.
>
>
____________________________________________________
Sell on Yahoo! Auctions – no fees. Bid on great items.
http://auctions.yahoo.com/