Responding to McNeile... ... Yes. As an additional spin on Balcer's answer, I would add that this is true of OOA/D in general rather than just eUML or the...
... Actually, I've seen compromise solutions where data was fetched from remote methods through stateless message exchange. Special messages were defined to...
Responding to Bestler... ... True. But there are <at least> two valid reasons for such variances at the OOP level. One is that OOA/D represents an abstract...
Alan Brain and I are presenting a paper 'Simulation Case Study - xtUML In Agile Development' at SIMTect 2004 in Canberra Australia, 24-27 May 2004. Conference...
Hi, can anyone give a good comparison between action languages related to UML, e.g. the OAL, and the MS Abstract State Machine Language (AsmL). Thanks. Jernej...
Dear Colleague, I would like to inform you that LogOn has a Web-based services called OT Land (see below). Registration is for free to OT Land, and articles of...
Roberto Zicari
zicari@...
May 19, 2004 5:12 am
714
Dear Colleague, I would like to inform you that LogOn is offering a two days conference and exhibits in Zurich on May 24 and 25. The event is free of charge,...
Roberto Zicari
zicari@...
May 19, 2004 5:13 am
715
Dear Colleague, could you please distribute this info as you see proper? LogOn and the Object Management Group are announcing an OMG Information Day, taking...
Roberto Zicari
zicari@...
May 25, 2004 1:46 pm
716
I recently heard a presentation about executable UML in which the conclusion recommended against the use of the methodology and the assessed tool (the KC tool...
I owe the group a more detailed reply to this posting, in large part because I've encountered it in several distinct settings in the past few weeks...evidence...
Marc; Thanks for your feedback. Your opinion (as well as everyone else's) is greatly appreciated. The presentation in question was given by a systems engineer...
... I'm not going to comment on specific tools, but one assertion really leaps out at me: the implication that not supporting UML 2.0 is some sort of violation...
My two-cent's worth.. i. Lack of support for UML.2.0.. Firstly this isn't yet a standard (though will be soon), secondly the UML2.0 (and previous versions) are...
Responding to Jeffstewart5... ... I'll go further than Balcer and assert that the presenter doesn't seem to understand the difference between OOA and OOP at...
... Considering the preconceived mindsets and lack of effort put into gaining experience before making judgement that I see at the large company I work for,...
... Is Action Semantics (UML 1.5) considered a UML 2.0 or UML 1 feature? I'm kind of confused in this respect. ... There have always been some basic flaws with...
Action Semantics was added in 1.5. That is the only difference between 1.4 and 1.5. Action Semantics are retained in 2.0, but under the guise of an Activity. ...
Stephen J. Mellor
steve@...
May 28, 2004 6:12 am
726
What happens when you evaluate a set of tools and ideas based on solving a different problem? They come up short! The speaker is evaluting the tools based on...
Stephen J. Mellor
steve@...
May 28, 2004 6:13 am
727
Stephen, Can you give me some concrete examples for your statement: "UML 2.0 is a lot of things, but has signally failed to address the problem of building...
respectfully ... I've got to be honest, your reply sounded a bit ad hominem to me. How do you know the speaker was evaluating the tools based upon modeling...
... Stephen: What do you mean by "consistency" in UML. Is this single-view consistency such as you cannot have a cycle of inheritances? Or, do you mean...
Responding to Mowers... ... I will give 3:1 that the answers would be false and true, respectively. B-) To the extent that we always abstract only the...
(i) Not unnecessary but irrelevant. It's an implementation idea, not relevant to analysis. The speaker's comment is akin to saying he didn't like the...
Stephen J. Mellor
steve@...
May 30, 2004 2:45 pm
732
I mean consistency between the diagrams. The UML spec focusses on defining the semantics of each diagram, but not how they fit together. A sequence diagram...
Stephen J. Mellor
steve@...
May 30, 2004 2:46 pm
733
Stepen & H. S. Lahman, Thanks. I appreciate the dialog. I'm almost persuaded :-) What about the idea of using data encapsulation in analysis in order to model...
... My approach to this is very simple: - No object makes references that are not required. - All requirements are modeled in analysis. Therefore there is no...
Hi, my name is Michael and i am interested in eUML in general. I was wondering if anyone has ever built a complete and productive database driven business app....
Responding to Mowers... ... My spin on this is a variation of my previous argument. Yes, the class needs a Color attribute -- if that is necessary to solving...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
