Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
extremeprogramming · Extreme Programming
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
"Agile Imposition is a Very Red Flag" - discuss   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #123315 of 152428 |
Re: [XP] "Agile Imposition is a Very Red Flag" - discuss

Hi Kent, all,

> I'm hoping Dale will jump in here, because he has a much
> better handle on these issues than I do. I'm not very good at
> staying "out of the sandbox", but I like the results when I
> do.

I'm not good at staying out of the sandbox either. But I've
gotten better at getting out once I notice I'm in. That's progress.

I'm focusing on a writing project right now, plus a few other
weekend tasks, and I don't have much time left over to think
about the topic at hand. If the thread still has legs after the
weekend I may have more time to reply. In the meantime, here are
a few pre-thought ideas that seem relevant.

Managers, being obligated to serve organizational intentions, and
being authorized to decide how to use the organization's
resources to serve those intentions, get to decide what they will
pay us for.

We, being adults, get to decide what we will do for the money and
other valuable things the organization provides for us, and get
to decide what else we want in exchange for and in support of our
services.

We and managers always have the option to seek to renegotiate any
of this.

Given that we're all XPers to some degree, we always have the
choice to interact with others, including managers, according to
the values we espouse: simplicity, respect, courage,
communication, and feedback.

A big part of courage is remembering that my needs matter. A big
part of respect is remembering that the other person's needs
matter. If I can remember these values I have a chance of
staying out of the sandbox, or of getting out gracefully.

Does any of that seem to apply?

Dale

--
Dale Emery, Consultant
Inspiring Leadership for Software People
Web: http://www.dhemery.com
Weblog: http://www.dhemery.com/cwd



Sat Oct 14, 2006 12:20 am

dalehemery
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #123315 of 152428 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Victor, You're right--I wasn't trying to present a balanced discussion. I was responding to what I saw as flaws in the original post--that only programmers can...
Kent Beck
kentlbeck
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
5:45 am

Hi Kent, all, ... I'm not good at staying out of the sandbox either. But I've gotten better at getting out once I notice I'm in. That's progress. I'm...
Dale Emery
dalehemery
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
12:20 am

Hello, Dale, all. Not bad at all for "pre-thought", Dale! I'm of a mind to riff on your thoughts. Below. On Friday, October 13, 2006, ... It's curious ... I...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
1:42 am

Hi Ron, ... Ooops. You've interpreted "pre-thought" too generously. I didn't mean to say that these things just popped into my head. My half-baked ideas...
Dale Emery
dalehemery
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
7:32 am

Hello, Dale. Interesting ... On Saturday, October 14, 2006, at ... Well, you deny on the one hand any notion of "rightness", and on the other hand call these...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
11:14 am

... And if we add Context to the mix, we get congruence. Very nice! -- ... * George Dinwiddie * gdinwiddie@... Software...
George Dinwiddie
gdinwiddie
Offline Send Email
Oct 18, 2006
2:37 am

Hello, Kent. Thanks for this contribution. I have some questions, more invitations to clarify your expression than actual objections. Again: I may seem to be...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
2:03 am

Ron, My point is that in all cases I can choose my response. If I receive an email that says, "Starting Monday you will be an Extreme Programmer," I choose how...
Kent Beck
kentlbeck
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
5:43 am

Hello, Kent. Total agreement. On Thursday, October 12, 2006, at ... Yes, absolutely. We have the ability to lead with any response available to us. I generally...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
9:52 am

... I don't think that. I believe I have the right to say that *I* will work in an Agile way. I have the right not to take jobs that won't let me, and I have...
Bill Caputo
logosity
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
4:27 am

I think this is part of a bigger problem that I call 'the death of locality' when I talk about it with friends. It just seems to work better when people...
Michael Feathers
mfeathers256
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
2:41 pm

Michael, There are certainly some actions and signals that are are suicidal in political enviroments. While I agree with your general point, in this particular...
Steven Gordon
sfman2k
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
4:07 pm

Steven, I don't think any of those things would've been useful. The team had been in death-march mode for a while and they were clearly exhausted. I think,...
Michael Feathers
mfeathers256
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
5:46 pm

Then the lack of anything to do was just an excuse. The real reason to give the team some time off was to recover from a death march. I would call it...
Steven Gordon
sfman2k
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
2:55 pm

Yes, we can see it that way, but it's moot. The team didn't take any time off. Ignoring the team for a second, I think that the real issue was the ability of...
Michael Feathers
mfeathers256
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
3:50 pm

Hello, Michael ... On Saturday, October 14, 2006, at 11:44:20 AM, ... I suspect that the specificity of your example masks your general question, which I agree...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
4:21 pm

Ron, I think it comes down to bandwidth. Imagine an organization with complete transparency.. there's still an issue of how much information any one person...
Michael Feathers
mfeathers256
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
4:59 pm

Hi Micheal, I don't think that there really can be too much transparency. We recently had a similar problem: we had publicly posted an information radiator,...
Ilja Preuss
ipreussde
Offline Send Email
Oct 23, 2006
5:08 pm

... Ilja, I agree with the principle that transparency is better, but I think there are some limits to its utility. In your example, when you released the...
Michael Feathers
mfeathers256
Offline Send Email
Oct 24, 2006
9:29 pm

It would be cool if a team can use the power of self-organization to use an agile process, but some people can't agree whether something is a floor wax or a...
Chris Gardner
chris_gardner76
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
1:06 pm

There are a lot of ways for a CEO (or "leadership team") to introduce change. This might be easier when there is a dire threat like the company going under,...
Keith Ray
attkeithray
Offline Send Email
Oct 12, 2006
3:40 pm

... Hi, Chris. I agree that people with power can use it to change the situation, but I'm not persuaded that ordering people to be agile would be very...
William Pietri
william_pietri
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
6:14 am

If there is significant resistance by say half, what might be some effective management approaches to sell agile? How long should the agile champions try to...
Chris Gardner
chris_gardner76
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
1:03 pm

Hello, Chris. A question. On Friday, October 13, 2006, at 5:59:16 ... What is management's purpose in "selling agile"? What would they get if they were able to...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
2:17 pm

... Perhaps a concrete example will be of use. In my organization, we have about 55 developers working XP style, more or less, on nine teams. Prior to...
Gary Brown
gb70840
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
6:41 pm

Gary, Excellent example. Maybe, management should have made it an invitation, something like: "Everyone is invitied to participate in the future reformation...
Steven Gordon
sfman2k
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
7:13 pm

... Truly devious! 8^) I wonder if that would have changed the result in any significant way. Would the get-along-gang be inspired? Would the selfish few...
Gary Brown
gb70840
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
7:31 pm

I'd fall over dead from shock if I heard that at my company. And when I got over that and ran to get in on the project, I'm pretty sure I would not be...
Jim Standley
jstandley2001
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
1:36 am

Hello, Gary. On Friday, October 13, 2006, at 11:40:50 AM, you ... I would suggest that yes, the VP was wrong to sell and impose XP. I suggest that, instead,...
Ron Jeffries
RonaldEJeffries
Offline Send Email
Oct 13, 2006
11:51 pm

... Perhaps we were naive. Perhaps doing XP on this scale is harder than we thought. Clearly though, the VP did set out the business objectives. He...
Gary Brown
gb70840
Offline Send Email
Oct 14, 2006
1:45 am
 First  |  |  Last 
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help