Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
flexcoders · RIA Development with Adobe Flex
  • Members Only
  • Post
  • Files
  • Photos
  • Polls
  • Groups Labs (Beta)
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Hear how Yahoo! Groups has changed the lives of others. Take me there.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

   Messages Help
Message #
Search:
Advanced
Flex Remoting Options - Any Opinions?   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #90819 of 149551 |
Hi all,

All I want to do is have my Flex client to communicate with my Java backend. Due to licensing restrictions, LCDS won't be an option for us. So far the biggest contenders are:

1. Granite Data Services
2. OpenAMF
3. WebORB
4. Red5

Does anyone have any strong opinions, suggestions, or biases on either of these solutions?

Thanks,

Bruce
Tue Oct 16, 2007 4:43 pm

Show Message Option
bruce1976
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward 		Message #90819 of 149551 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi all, All I want to do is have my Flex client to communicate with my Java backend. Due to licensing restrictions, LCDS won't be an option for us. So far the ... 		Bruce Hopkins
bruce1976
Offline Send Email 		Oct 16, 2007
4:44 pm

You can also just use HTTPService to do direct HTTP requests. I am using this for communications with a JAVA backend. ... backend. ... far the ... either of...
Jeff Schuenke
mirageviddeo1
Offline Send Email 		Oct 16, 2007
4:49 pm

Yeah, I'm using HTTPService right now with E4X results. The for large data results, however, XML is not desirable. I'd prefer to use some framework that uses...
Bruce Hopkins
bruce1976
Offline Send Email 		Oct 16, 2007
6:01 pm

Bruce, None of the options you have would work for serious production application unless you invest heavily in making the client and server code more reliable....
Anatole Tartakovsky
anatolet
Offline Send Email 		Oct 16, 2007
7:50 pm

Has the pricing been improved on LCDS? When I last looked into FDS it was ~20k EUR per CPU, which is just silly....
Paul Dale
pauldale11
Offline Send Email 		Oct 16, 2007
7:55 pm

Is there anyway to judge what level of user connections a given server can handle without requiring specialized loadsharing strategies? In a non-audio or video...
Steve Hueners
juststeve
Offline Send Email 		Nov 15, 2007
7:55 pm

That part is not AMF specific - and Apache or Tomcat will have no issues of doing it - that is purely bandwidth issue. As far as AMF/RTMP streaming main issue...
Anatole Tartakovsky
anatolet
Offline Send Email 		Nov 15, 2007
8:28 pm

I'd like to repeat Steven's question. I'm really curious about this. How many simultaneous connections can LCDS handle on one CPU? I realize that this will...
Douglas McCarroll
douglasmccar...
Offline Send Email 		Nov 26, 2007
9:56 am

... My guess is that it works out cheaper to buy a faster single CPU than to upgrade the LCDS license. -- Tom Chiverton Helping to administratively...
Tom Chiverton
tom.chiverton
Offline Send Email 		Nov 27, 2007
2:00 pm

I have a question related to this topic as well. What has peoples experience been with open source solutions like AMFPHP for remoting, or Python for persistent...
Aaron Miller
amiller@...
Send Email 		Nov 27, 2007
4:04 pm

Well, yes, but this approach will only take us so far... even with Moore's law in action. Does anyone have a significant app running on LCDS Express? How many ...
Douglas McCarroll
douglasmccar...
Offline Send Email 		Nov 28, 2007
2:45 am

... large data ... more compact ... am ... 40yahoogroups.com>, "Bruce ... Java ... So ... I can tell you what my experience has been so far with Granite Data ...
tomeuchre
Offline Send Email 		Oct 17, 2007
12:30 pm

Tom, Thanks for your feed back on GDS. I have one question for you though. When I ran the simple Pojo example, I saw in the output from my Tomcat server that ...
Bruce Hopkins
bruce1976
Offline Send Email 		Oct 17, 2007
3:22 pm

... When I ... server that ... know ... If have run full DEBUG and see that the message from the AMFMessageFilter.doFilter method outputs a line stating...
tomeuchre
Offline Send Email 		Oct 17, 2007
5:25 pm

Thanks!...
Bruce Hopkins
bruce1976
Offline Send Email 		Oct 17, 2007
8:41 pm

PS - I did something that Granite didn't think was possible (or at least very easy to do): I got Granite Data Services working with Flex making remote AMF3/rpc...
tomeuchre
Offline Send Email 		Oct 18, 2007
12:40 pm

Hello, I am just starting to use graniteDS and starting to likie it. My -ONLY- problem was that, I cannot make it work from within my flexbuilder environment. ...
mattmadhavan
Offline Send Email 		Nov 15, 2007
6:53 pm

Why not? Is it 'cause your app runs from the file system within flexbuilder and the web host in production/test? If that's the case then move to Flex Builder...
Samuel R. Neff
sam_atellis
Offline Send Email 		Nov 15, 2007
6:58 pm

Sam, Do you mind sending me the step by step instructions? I just cannot make it work. I have two project - 1. Java web project for the java server side (Say ...
mattmadhavan
Offline Send Email 		Nov 15, 2007
7:56 pm

... Btw: if you want AMF3 support you can rule out OpenAMF and WebORB which only support AMF0. Furthermore, since early November there is a new option:...
Jens Halm
spicefactory...
Offline Send Email 		Nov 16, 2007
7:51 pm

... I'm pretty sure that the update for WebORB for Java (Due out next week I understand) will support AMF3. However, such updates are not yet reflected on the...
Jeffry Houser
reboog711
Offline Send Email 		Nov 16, 2007
8:46 pm
< Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Message #
Search:
Advanced
Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help