Hi, While conducting a FMEA session, if different participants select different severity rankings, how do you decide on the "final" severity ranking? For eg....
Hello, Is is normal that you can have long discussions about the correct severity ranking. Most of the discussions are not about the higher rankings 9, 10 and...
Dear Robert, Your approach seems to be an acceptable way of resolving the issue of differing rankings. Another approach we have used rather successfully is to:...
I had adopted a system of clearly displaying the factors affecting severity, e.g. 1. Impared performance 2. loss of function, but system will run ... 5....
Hello, I fully agree with your comment not to average the figures and go for the worst case scenario. Importend is that we make clear rules, which are...
hi, I am new to these arguments. in these days I have tried to create fmea of an electronic circuit. Now I would want to add the data in order to obtain a...
Dear friends 1) Please help me in finding FMEA Examples from Telecommunication Service Provider Industry 2) Can you please suggest links where I can find...
580
Twincy Nirmala
ntwincy@...
Nov 1, 2006 3:23 pm
Hi everyone, I am been assigned to do a Design FMEA of a pneumatic system used in Aircarfts. It has different levels of components . Main assembly Sub Assembly...
Normally, System level DFMEA will be done first and Component level DFMEA is the last stage. True, customer requirement is specified for system level only. To...
I am recently tasked to implement DFMEA for our hardware design office. Can anyone advise whether there should there be separate DFMEA for EE and ME and why? ...
Hi, I want the explaination of SWFMEA with an example. Regards, Padmavathi B...
584
Jose Luis Gimeno
jlgimeno@...
Feb 14, 2007 11:49 am
Hi, I'm just a starter in this matter, and hope you can help me with one question. When I get a DFMEA where Potentially Critical Characteristics (YC) are ...
Jose, I assume that you are using the 9 and 10 Severity ratings for characteristics that could cause an injury to an employee or customer. Given the potential...
586
mabmon@...
Feb 24, 2007 11:30 am
Hi, I'm an Italian Technical Writer, and I found two interesting (obviously this is my opinion,,) Here attached I'm sending this material. Many greetings. ...
I have been doing FMEA's for a couple of years at my company. We have been ranking occurences based on the probability of the root cause occuring rather that...
Hi all! I'm making kind of research for FMEA. Has anyone here has, knows or at least saw any information on the data for FMEA usage. I've found tonns of...
... 1.Ty.for your mail. 2.FMEA with respect to health care organisation and risk management would be a good starter .Prior to evaluate FMEA , you need to...
Leo, Can you kindly provide some reading material references in this field? Will appreciate. RV ... 1.Ty.for your mail. 2.FMEA with respect to health care...
Hi, I just wanted to know whether Risk analysis for medical devices can be done in FMEA format. Some say that risk analysis is different from FMEA. Can one ...
598
judit.guenther@...
Oct 8, 2007 9:13 am
Hi, FMEA is a kind of risk analysis, and it can be also used in health care. In preparation to FMEA you can make QFD, FTA or some other brain storming and...
Hi, Can anyone tell me, for modifying the existing process for improving productivity, whether I need to review the PFMEA for the existing process and...
600
eric-sl_phoon@...
Oct 26, 2007 7:57 am
Vaithi It depends on what is the physical stage you are at, if you are at the old process stage, and only plan for new process now, PFMEA should be on existing...
601
judit.guenther@...
Oct 26, 2007 7:57 am
Hi Vaithi, first decide the new process steps and do a FMEA for it. As FMEA is a risk analysis, so you must first know what you want to do - process...
602
D P Ghosh
dpghosh@...
Oct 26, 2007 7:57 am
Hello Vaithi, I would suggest you to do the Process reengineering first. Then you need to carry out FMEA to know the robustness of your control over the ...
... design (Design FMEA)which are special (All characteristics are important) but there are some which are directly linked to performance of the product which...
I like to suggestthat facilitators split the severity table into three distinct areas, 9,10 resrved for Safety and Regulatory, 5 through 8 for primary...
