Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
futarchy_discuss · Discussion about futarchy
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Measuring Welfare   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #35 of 65 |
Re: [futarchy_discuss] Measuring Welfare

> >I would make it clear to survey respondents that personal
> circumstantial
> well-being is what's being asked about. So the survey question would be
> something like "Are you better off than you were N years ago?"
>
> You could be better off or worse off just because of changes in age. Most
> 25
> year olds are better off then most 95 year olds for non government related
> reasons. So if you ask ""Are you better off than you were N years ago?""
> all
> sorts of factors relating to the persons age are brought in.

That is true.

I'm tempted to suggest framing the question in a way that excluded mere
age. Something like "Other than being N years older than you were, are you
better off than you were N years ago?"

But then it occurred to me that to the extent that aging influences
people's well-being, mitigating it is a legitimate concern.

Even if this metric will predictably fall (or rise) as the population
ages, it's not a problem. What matters is the expected differential of
GDP+ between different policies, not GDP+'s value as such. I see no
reason that a predictable externally-caused change in GDP+ would change
investors' preferences.


>>Drazen Prelec's "Bayesian Truth Serum" (BTS)
> That is a really interesting concept. Thanks for pointing it out.

You're welcome.

> David
>




Thu Mar 27, 2008 9:08 pm

tehom2000
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #35 of 65 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Bhutan is trying to define national welfare http://www.physorg.com/news125462439.html "The main concerns have been identified as psychological well-being,...
David Curran
iamreddave
Offline Send Email
Mar 25, 2008
2:08 pm

... Life expectancy provides a fairly objective measure that is rather highly correlated with the concerns that I care about. Some care needs to be taken to...
Peter C. McCluskey
pcmgeek
Offline Send Email
Mar 26, 2008
3:34 am

... I'm glad you asked that. I would include a component to measure self-reported satisfaction. Now, self-reported satisfaction ("happiness") is notoriously ...
Tom Breton (Tehom)
tehom2000
Offline Send Email
Mar 27, 2008
2:55 am

I see many problems with these suggested measures Lifespan can be extended in all sorts of authoritarian ways. Ban smoking is an obvious one. Is there any way...
David Curran
iamreddave
Offline Send Email
Mar 27, 2008
11:27 am

... The law of unintended consequences. This sort of discussion is largely an attempt to anticipate those consequences. ... Or, is there a way to measure...
Tom Breton (Tehom)
tehom2000
Offline Send Email
Mar 27, 2008
5:45 pm

... well-being is what's being asked about. So the survey question would be something like "Are you better off than you were N years ago?" You could be better...
David Curran
iamreddave
Offline Send Email
Mar 27, 2008
6:09 pm

... That is true. I'm tempted to suggest framing the question in a way that excluded mere age. Something like "Other than being N years older than you were,...
Tom Breton (Tehom)
tehom2000
Offline Send Email
Mar 27, 2008
9:09 pm

... If we had a good measure of psychological well-being, that should solve this problem. I doubt we can solve the problem without measuring psychological...
Peter C. McCluskey
pcmgeek
Offline Send Email
Mar 28, 2008
9:01 pm

... You make a good point. Especially "how they think they ought to have felt" - that's something I hadn't considered. On the other hand, even though I summed...
Tom Breton (Tehom)
tehom2000
Offline Send Email
Mar 29, 2008
6:33 pm

... By not asking them to do intertemporal comparisons. You appear to have suggested doing those comparisons in order to solve problems associated with...
Peter C. McCluskey
pcmgeek
Offline Send Email
Mar 31, 2008
9:20 pm

... It seems to me that satisfaction reports are implicitly some sort of intertemporal comparison. Or at least the alternative bases for satisfaction reports...
Tom Breton (Tehom)
tehom2000
Offline Send Email
Apr 1, 2008
1:59 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help