Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
lambengolmor
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want to share photos of your group with the world? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
"Tolkien in Oxford"   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #934 of 1084 |
Re: "Tolkien in Oxford"

>_arcastar mondósaresse_

Very interesting! I cannot resist analyzing this right away:

_mondósaresse_ 'in Oxford'

In Letter no.342 Tolkien gives "the elvish word for 'bull'" as _mundo_
(apparently in Quenya), so that one can identify _mondo_ 'ox' here.
An element 'ford, crossing' would be then expected to follow and
indeed _-sar-_ can be related to THAR- 'across, beyond' (V:392), also
_thar-_ 'athwart, across' in the _Silmarillion_ glossary with _Tharbad_
< _thara-pata_ 'crossway'.

[Note also numerous Q. words in _sar-_ having to do with stones or
stoniness, as _sarne_ 'stony place' < SAR- (V:385, VT46:12). CFH]

The long _-ó-_ seems to suggest that one should isolate _#ósar(e)_
'ford', rather than just _#sar(e)_ with the prefix _ó-_ 'used in words
describing the meeting, junction, or union of two things or persons,
or of two groups thought of as units' (XI:367); and _-s-_ < _th_ would
naturally resist rhotacism here.

The ending _-sse_ is of course locative, while the vowel _-e-_ before
it may belong to the preceding word (#_ósare-sse_) or just link the
ending to it (#_ósar-e-sse_).

_arcastar_ 'Tolkien'

Tolkien's name is an anglicization of _Tollkiehn_ , German _tollkühn_
'foolhardy, reckless, desperately brave' (compare Letter no.165),
containing _toll_ 'insane, mad, wild' and _kühn_ 'brave'. A more or
less literal translation into English Tolkien himself also made, was
'Rashbold' (IX:151).

I would analyze the Quenya word as _*arca-star_.

The initial element _arca-_ looks similar to Q _arauka_ 'swift,
rushing' (PE12:34) from RAVA or RAWA (PE12:79) with many derivatives
for chase, running, hunting, fierceness; also _rauka_ = _arauka_ 'swift'.
But of course a diphthong cannot be syncopated, so that one has to
assume a different derivation from a changed or parallel root, e.g. <
_*araka_ < (A)RAK- (?); cf. Q _narka_ 'to rend' from NÁRAK- 'tear, rend
(tr. and intr.)' (V:374, VT45:37).

The latter element _-star_ seems to be related to STAR- 'stiff'
(V:388), with _st_ preserved medially. Although this stem yields words
for grass only — Q _sara_ 'stiff, dry grass, bent', N _thâr_ 'stiff
grass' and so on — there is a different root TÁRAG- 'tough, stiff'
producing Q _tarya_ 'tough, stiff' and N. _tarias_ 'stiffness, toughness,
difficulty', _tarlanc_'stiff-necked, obstinate' with reference to more
abstract meanings. Hence, _arcastar_ would be something like
*'rushing [and] stiff-necked'.

[I like your analysis, though I think _-star_ as 'stiff' (without any
reference to necks) is a fine rendering of the sense of 'hardy' in
'foolhardy', both as physically 'hard, tough' and as metaphorically
'unyielding, resolute'. CFH]

Roman Rausch






Fri Oct 27, 2006 3:10 pm

rausch_roman
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #934 of 1084 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Mellyn! In Christie's sale November 15 (catalogue named _Valuable Printed Books and Manuscripts_), lot 152 is an inscribed set of _The Lord of the Rings_,...
Beregond. Anders Sten...
j_beregond
Offline Send Email
Oct 27, 2006
12:44 pm

Thanks to Anders for passing along notice of this very interesting letter! I can add one bit of information not mentioned in the exhibit catalogue, which is...
Carl F. Hostetter
endorendil
Offline Send Email
Oct 27, 2006
3:25 pm

... That should read "placed _above_ the consonant", of course; sorry for the typo. Carl...
Carl F. Hostetter
endorendil
Offline Send Email
Oct 27, 2006
5:40 pm

... I read the first line and a half in this way: "Here {or "Above"?} are some specimens. A is a transliteration of English. But this happens " [Aha! I think...
Beregond. Anders Sten...
j_beregond
Offline Send Email
Oct 28, 2006
6:22 pm

... The catalogue has arrived, and everything is legible. The words above the second line of tengwar are: "In Elvish language & script" The note in green...
Beregond. Anders Sten...
j_beregond
Offline Send Email
Nov 6, 2006
12:48 pm

Beregond/Anders Stenström wrote: ... ... May I ask for the last sign of the second tengwar transcription of 'Mondósaresse'? On the scan available at...
j_mach_wust
Offline Send Email
Nov 6, 2006
2:13 pm

... There is an 'acute' below the ascender of the esse. Suilad, Beregond...
"Beregond. Anders Ste...
j_beregond
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2006
3:53 am

... Very interesting! I cannot resist analyzing this right away: _mondósaresse_ 'in Oxford' In Letter no.342 Tolkien gives "the elvish word for 'bull'" as...
Roman Rausch
rausch_roman
Offline Send Email
Oct 27, 2006
3:59 pm

... What about connecting _-(a)sta-r_ with Tulkas's title: _Astaldo_ 'The Valiant'? In my humble opinion the second element in the name _Mondósar(e)_ 'Oxford'...
Richard Derdzinski
galadhorn
Offline Send Email
Oct 28, 2006
2:10 am

... I believe that _Astaldo_ should be rather related to STÁLAG- with primitive _stalga_ 'stalwart, steady, firm', N _thalion_ 'hero, dauntless man' (V:388)...
Roman Rausch
rausch_roman
Offline Send Email
Oct 28, 2006
4:16 pm

... In Note 24 to Quendi and Eldar, we learn that "[m]edial z < s had became r in the Ńoldorin dialect of Q except when an adjacent syllable, or (as here) the...
Andreas Johansson
andjo@...
Send Email
Nov 1, 2006
7:01 pm

... Hm. I thought the stress in _Mondósaresse_ would lie on the _e_ preceding the double consonant _ss_ (according to the pronunciation rules as for example...
hisilome
Offline Send Email
Nov 5, 2006
1:41 am

Hello, ... This is the realm of guesswork: the rule, as given, does imply that we could have _s_/_r_ alternations in the paradigm relative to stress (witness...
Pavel Iosad
pavel_iosad
Offline Send Email
Nov 6, 2006
12:49 pm

... My original objection was mainly to Roman's statement that in _Mondósaresse_ the _s_ is followed by the stressed vowel, which is patently false (if one...
hisilome
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2006
12:40 pm

On reflection, I think that I should relay the following thought to the list. As I had shown Beregond's [Anders Stenström's] initial post and Christie's lot...
Harm J. Schelhaas
mithrennaith
Offline Send Email
Nov 7, 2006
11:49 pm

... An example for an ancient compound with rhotacism carried out seems to exist, namely: Q _Tindómerel_ *'daughter/child of twilight' (V:385) with the...
Roman Rausch
rausch_roman
Offline Send Email
Nov 9, 2006
3:15 am

... The wild thought has occurred to me to read it as *_ar-cas+ta-r_: an agent noun in _-r_ to a verb *_casta-_ (in turn formed by adding causative _-ta_ to...
Jerome Colburn
jcolburn@...
Send Email
Nov 1, 2006
6:59 pm

Just a minor correction: For me the first word of the Elvish greeting (inscribed by Tolkien in the copy of _The Fellowship of the Ring_ being auctioned) reads...
Florian Dombach
florian_loth...
Offline Send Email
Oct 28, 2006
4:04 pm

It has long appeared to me that as printed in _The Peoples of Middle-earth_ (XII:295-320), the essay 'Of Dwarves and Men' is strangely circular in disposition....
F.S.
frestro
Offline Send Email
Oct 28, 2006
8:44 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help