Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
mpml · A list for asteroid and comet researcher
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want your group to be featured on the Yahoo! Groups website? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
2003 EL61 named Haumea by CSBN/WGPSN   Message List  
Reply Message #20986 of 23031 |
IAUC 8976 announces that the CSBN and the WGPSN
have accepted the name "Haumea" for the TNO 2003 EL61.
This was the name proposal of the self-proclaimed discoverers
Brown et al., not of the official discoverers Ortiz et al.

I don't know if this is the first time that the CSBN stripped off
the discoverer's naming rights. But this time it became very
obvious what this old men's club gives about rules and fairness.

Brown et al. did not report any astrometric line to the MPC
until the object was nearly numbered. Yet they had the arrogance to
claim discovery credit and to request naming rights, and due to their
personal connections to Brian Marsden, the CSBN secretary,
their name proposal was pushed in CSBN and finally favoured and
accepted over the discoverer's proposal.
Actually Marsden announced his unjust intentions already in
his Sept. 15, 2005 CCNet article: "Presumably, matters can be
taken care of--and without a lot of fanfare--when 2003 EL61 is given
a permanent number and name."

In the economy such a behaviour is called "corruption".
Congratulations gentlemen!

So far, MPC lists Ortiz et al. as discoverers of (136108) 2003 EL61.
It wouldn't surprise me if Brown and his puppy are trying to falsify the
MPC records too.

R.





Wed Sep 17, 2008 7:39 pm

rms1kpde
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Message #20986 of 23031 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

IAUC 8976 announces that the CSBN and the WGPSN have accepted the name "Haumea" for the TNO 2003 EL61. This was the name proposal of the self-proclaimed...
Reiner M. Stoss
rms1kpde
Offline Send Email
Sep 17, 2008
7:39 pm

... Reiner, If you know the name proposed by the official discoverers, perhaps you might reveal it, so those who are sensitive to the issue and agree with what...
Alan W Harris
harrisaw
Offline Send Email
Sep 17, 2008
8:10 pm

Alan, ... I don't care about the names at all. I have to admit that I cannot recall names or numbers as good as provisional designations, so I mostly use only...
Reiner M. Stoss
rms1kpde
Offline Send Email
Sep 17, 2008
9:06 pm

... Dear Reiner, I have to say I am not too pleased by that name, and will certainly not use it. I think in assigning names, astronomers should heed the part...
Alan W Harris
harrisaw
Offline Send Email
Sep 18, 2008
12:11 am

Gee, a weird argument by Alan Harris... This is the first discovery of importance from the spanish group, and it is not shocking to use a spanish related...
Alain Maury
geocroiseur
Offline Send Email
Sep 18, 2008
3:22 am

Alan, ... The CSBN *was* discussing a "neutral" name. One member of CSBN proposed the name "Dagda", a god from Irish mythology: ...
Reiner M. Stoss
rms1kpde
Offline Send Email
Sep 18, 2008
9:47 am

... only ... I see that the list of discovery details of the numbered minor planets has been updated. The discovery credit for 136108 is still given to the...
gward1975
Offline Send Email
Sep 18, 2008
9:30 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help