Marc, ... I think that your distinction is nonsense. Let me explain. An ontology is a formal specification of a shared conceptualisation. My requirement means...
Martin, By no means is it correct to state that the MVCO is a "conceptualization of copyright law" this assertion is incorrect and I for one do not adhere to...
... I don't object to your requirement but I disagree that my requirement is a more specific wording of mine. Let's assume a developer wants to develop an...
ll, the attached news might be interesting in connection with our discussions. Note the license under which the BBC have published their ontology. Cheers, ...
Martin, Xin, All, My rewording of Martin's equirement was to specifically avoid confusing royalties for using the ontology from royalties for the use being...
Marc, We are talking of two different things 1. the fact that we want to enable those practising the MVCO standard to do so without paying royalties 2....
Leonardo, That is my point I do not think that it is an area that we should include. Unfettered access is sufficient because it states that within whatever...
Marc, I keep on being terribly confused. I think this is a discussion that should be concluded at the meeting. We are spending Hertzian and mental bandwidth...
Leonardo, The problem is two fold: 1) The requirement proposed makes a categorical statement about remuneration of proposed contributions without taking...
Marc, ... PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE. MPEG does not have fees or royalties or anything. As per the ISO/IEC directives I request people who attend MPEG meetings to ...
Leonardo, I was referring to the fee required to access a certified copy my understanding is that it is not free of charge. Apologies if I am mistaken. Marc ...
Dear all, I am also considering what Xin says. Independently of the wording of the requirement, if this is something that MPEG never required before, I would...
Marc, There are no “certified copies”. There are copies of the standard that implementors may need to buy from ISO/IEC. And, as you know, a cost is ...
Leonardo, Thank you for that clarification and indeed it was that that I was referring to since I have never been able to obtain a free copy of any ISO...
Dear all, One of the objectives of the AhG was to prepare a Draft Call for Proposals. To support this point, please find attached a preliminary text I have ...
Dear colleagues, Here you are a proposed Draft AhG Report. I still need to check it with Xin, the other co-chair, but he is probably on travel and I do not...
ear All, I read a copy of N9906 and looked for my Requirements for the MVCO. Well, 2.11 is in the list, but where is my other Requirement (see attachment)? I...
Dear all, This is to kick off this AHG on CfP for a Media Value Chain Ontology. The mandates are: To address the following issues to evaluate the Call for...
Xin, ... Thanks for kicking-off the AhG. ... Do you have an initial proposal for the schedule? Will you arrange for a room for Sunday? Regards, Jaime....
Jaime and all, I have requested a meeting room for Sunday the 20th, 10am-1pm and 2pm-5pm. We will mainly go through mandate items 3-5 (below). Once I get a...
Dear all, I was informed by Joern Ostermann (the MPEG Requirements chair) that there are two proposals from ETRI and sDAE+UPC. The proponents should register...
Dear All, At that the last meeting two subsissions were made to the CfP sDae/UPC and Etri and the work has progressed to the Working Draft stage for the new...
Martin, I have copied this to MVCO as I think that it is interesting material for some of the members that have not subscribed to the editing list. My...
Martin all an important correction to my last post: I would like to discuss these things with your experts in copyright exceptions. Are they subscribed to this...
It is the hour that we answer mails and preparing my trip : My original text as follows was fine and my correction wrong: MG: The ontology has provided hooks...
Dear All, Please find attached the draft AHG Report as of the end of our meeting today. Regards, Marc Gauvin ADVERTENCIA DE CONFIDENCIALIDAD: La informacin...
Having problems with message search?
Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.
