Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
open-research-society · OPEN RESEARCH SOCIETY
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Want to share photos of your group with the world? Add a group photo to Flickr.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Introduction & Views   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #21 of 386 |
Re: Alternatives to standard peer review

Dear Konstantinos and dear all,

That's an important point. Open research is *not only* open journals,
but open conferences, open research projects, open Ph.Ds. etc.

I would like to comment some on these other issues:

1) The MTSR'05 (I am one of the organizers) is an on-line conference
that promotes the importance of on-line discussion, since the
proceedings are printed AFTER the discussions, so that there is time
to integrate them. See here:

http://www.metadata-semantics.org/

The deadline is still open (and the fees are low!), consider
submitting your work, it would be very nice to have some of you in
the conference!

2) We organized at my Univ. a workshop in "blended" mode, with no
registration fees, called ONTOSE:

http://www.cc.uah.es/msicilia/ws-onto/

It was a wonderful experience from my viewpoint. You can read a
report on the last SIGSEMIS bulletin:
http://www.sigsemis.org/newsletter/july2005/vol2_issue2.pdf


3) I started some kind of "open Ph.D." with some foreign students,
that is, they apply for the program at my Univ. and I give them the
possibility to do the seminars on-line. Then, the actual Ph.D. work
is conducted at a distance, with a co-supervisor in the other country
(from now, this is working between Greece and Spain). This is an
answer for people that are not interested in the programs offered at
their countries or regions and want to start a research collaboration
witouth the need to move for several years to other country.

Just some thoughs...

All the best,
Miguel-Angel



--- In open-research-society@yahoogroups.com, "K. Kotis" <kkot@a...>
wrote:
> Dear fellows,
>
> indeed, an alternative Journal would be the one that offers such
services
> that will certainly encourage new researchers to try out for their
skills
> for their first time! However, I believe that also experienced
researchers
> will be tempted to submit breakthrough ideas, ...ideas that
elsewhere (in
> traditional Journals and their reviewers) would have been almost
certainly
> rejected.
>
> In my opinion, the open research initiative should not only consider
> Journals as a medium of realizing this great idea. An alternative
medium
> could be an Open Conference, a conference for Open people with Open
ideas.
> In such a way, the open research society will have its own space
and time to
> exchange research and socialize in a completely different way than
the
> traditional conferences. Just imagine an annual international
conference
> (could be "virtual"?) where research papers will not be left out
because of
> the conference schedule (or limit of pages)!!!! Or even more
differently,
> think of a conference session where the "best rejected" papers will
have the
> chance to become accepted, not by a board of reviewers, but by the
highly
> qualified audience...!
>
> I hope these ideas to be further elaborated and become the new
roadmap of
> research for the common interest.
>
> Regards,
>
> Konstantinos
>
> _____







Mon Aug 22, 2005 8:11 am

masicilia
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #21 of 386 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi All, I am Ponnurangam K (PK), I am a second year PhD. student in the School of Computer Science and my areas of research range from representing privacy...
ponguru
Offline Send Email
Aug 18, 2005
9:12 pm

I have read with interest the various arguments on the editorial / journal system and process. My argument, to reiterate, is to brake away from traditional...
Christian Wagner
netom1
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2005
6:41 am

Dear Christian and dear all, I agree with you Christian in that something different to standard peer review should be done in a open research society. However,...
masicilia
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2005
8:46 am

Dear All, I think the problem we have here is a trade-off between rigorous academic review and the length of time that is necessary to complete the process. It...
Peter Bloodsworth
pcbloods
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2005
12:00 pm

Dear fellows, indeed, an alternative Journal would be the one that offers such services that will certainly encourage new researchers to try out for their...
K. Kotis
k0stas_k0tis
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2005
5:42 pm

Hi, I am a bit late with my proposal on how to deal with research quality ensurance. I think it would fit most the idea of an open research society that: (1)...
sclafwagen
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2005
8:11 pm

Dear all, From my point of view as a (soon to begin) PhD student open research means that a research publication is open to criticize or promote. From that...
Nikos Korfiatis
korfiatisnick
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2005
9:10 pm

Dear Konstantinos and dear all, That's an important point. Open research is *not only* open journals, but open conferences, open research projects, open Ph.Ds....
masicilia
Offline Send Email
Aug 22, 2005
8:11 am
< Prev Topic  |  Next Topic >
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help