As part of the RSS Advisory Board becoming custodian of the Media RSS specification, I've prepared a copy of the spec here: http://www.rssboard.org/media-rss ...
+1 in favor weppos wrote: As posted in a previous topic, I vote in favor of the proposal. Also, I can agree to the request to leave the namespace untouched...
As posted in a previous topic, I vote in favor of the proposal. Also, I can agree to the request to leave the namespace untouched since my previous message...
Today begins the one week period of voting to transfer publication of the mRSS spec to the board. Please review Rogers proposal (see following message). ...
... I think it's good that you've called attention to this aspect of the proposal. It will help ensure that board members know the significance of that...
... I agree. But I don't think it's asking a lot to expect some clarification from board members about whether they really would stick to that promise. Given...
... The confusion occurs because namespace URIs look like web addresses, so people naturally think that when the web address changes the URI should change as...
... I think that's a little naive. I'd hate to think that the board couldn't vote to correct past mistakes, even if that means allowing the board to undo good...
... The phrase "Finally, the board resolves that the namespace URI for Media RSS will remain "http://search.yahoo.com/mrss/" for as long as it is published to...
... And yet we've already had two board members suggest that it would be ok to change the namespace URI in the future. I would not feel comfortable having...
I agree both with the proposal and the suggestion to move the namespace at some point. What are your plans for the http://video.search.yahoo.com/mrss URL? Will...
It makes sense to me to have the Board as the central reference point for all things RSS. so I'm in favor of this proposal. I could see down the road maybe...
The following RSS Advisory Board proposal has been made by Rogers Cadenhead and seconded by Ryan Parman. Under the advisory board charter, the board has seven...
The RSS Advisory Board is now running a local copy of the Feed Validator: http://rssboard.org/rss-validator I'm still making some adjustments to the...
IMHO, I don't understand how anybody thinks that rssCloud could possibly work. There's simply too many scenarios where the spec fails. See scenarios of failure...
... If we defer to Dave, he will control RSSCloud and the most likely outcome is that the spec will be imprecise, he will declare it frozen and we won't be in...
... I agree that the process of creating a spec unilaterally by a single (or even small group of people!) is not a good thing. I don't believe 'we' as the RSS...
You've pretty much summed up my feelings on it. I think this is a responsibility that the Board should take on. I do think that Winer's changes have merit,...
I've written my thoughts on the subject on my blog. http://workbench.cadenhead.org/news/3559 The short version is that one person should not be allowed to...
