Skip to search.
rss-public

Group Information

  • Members: 325
  • Category: XML
  • Founded: Jan 22, 2006
  • Language: English
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Purpose of the RSS Advisory Board?   Message List  
Reply Message #152 of 2009 |
Hi folks,

I was about to email this to one of the Board members, but I figured
I'd post here instead since other people may have the same questions.

I just browsed rssboard.org, and my understanding is that the
purpose of the RSS Advisory Board is to clarify the existing RSS 2.0
specification. If this is true, then great - a clear set of specs
would help everyone in the RSS community (including myself). I'm
especially glad to see HTML and escaped text being discussed, since
this is an area that has been a problem for RSS developers for far
too long.

However, I'm concerned that a side goal of the Board is (or will be)
to come up with a revised specification that "fixes" RSS 2.0,
resulting in a new version of RSS. Is this concern justified, or am
I reading too much into these posts?

Also, I have to ask: what is Dave Winer's role in this? When I
heard that the RSS Advisory Board was starting again, I assumed it
was his doing. But I don't see any posts from him - is he keeping
quiet, or is he not involved here?

Thanks,
---
Nick Bradbury
http://nick.typepad.com/







Mon Feb 13, 2006 9:59 pm

bradbury_sof...
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Message #152 of 2009 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi folks, I was about to email this to one of the Board members, but I figured I'd post here instead since other people may have the same questions. I just...
Nick Bradbury
bradbury_sof... Offline Send Email
Feb 13, 2006
9:59 pm

... The purpose of the proposed specification is to document the Really Simple Syndication format as it exists today, not make changes to the format. The goal...
rcade Offline Send Email Feb 13, 2006
10:23 pm

... the format. I wonder if that goal is attainable. I would suggest any new text will be perceived by somebody as a change. Clarifying that item title is ...
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 13, 2006
10:46 pm

... Possibly. But if that's a change, what was the rule before the change? If something's unclear or underspecified, I think there's a lot of room for...
rcade Offline Send Email Feb 13, 2006
11:10 pm

I suspect most will say escaped HTML. Each clarification we make is unfortunately going to be interpreted as a change by someone. The difference between...
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
3:05 pm

... My guess is that if you ask most people, the only answer you are going to get is something along the lines of "my template looks like this; I don't...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
4:49 pm

One hour before Nick posed his question, I said on this list. But further, the statement "RSS documents that conform to this specification also conform to its...
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
5:08 pm

... You know as well as I do that that's not the question I am referring to. There is a *big* elephant in this room. - Sam Ruby...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
5:16 pm

Ok ... well ... I'll give there. I know nothing and that's not dodging. I truly don't care. Randy ... to....
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
5:26 pm

... I'm not going to speak on behalf of Andrew, Brent, Dave or Jon about the discussions we had prior to the recruitment of new advisory board members and the...
rcade Offline Send Email Feb 14, 2006
6:29 pm

... <snip /> ... <snip /> ... And what may I ask would be wrong with revising the specification to "fix" that which is dysfunctional? Usage of date-time values...
Clinton Gallagher
pocketchange... Offline Send Email
Feb 14, 2006
5:34 pm

... Indeed, and avoiding the question is no doubt posing an impediment to greater participation. -Bill Kearney Syndic8.com...
Bill Kearney
wkearney99 Offline Send Email
Feb 15, 2006
4:46 am

... referring to. ... I disagree. I find this process to be roughly the same, and about as open as an IETF Working Group. It's just that there are different ...
robertsayre2000 Offline Send Email Feb 17, 2006
1:18 am

Once again Robert, you insult me by mentionning only the elephants and forgetting about us little stubby fat rats :-p Randy...
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 17, 2006
1:36 am

I appreciate everyone's responses here, but I'm afraid I'm still confused. Randy, you state that "the purpose of the proposed specification is to document the...
Nick Bradbury
bradbury_sof... Offline Send Email
Feb 17, 2006
6:30 pm

Nick, Any clarification will be viewed as a change by some. As Sam points out, clarification=change. We can't really avoid that. That's why I proposed we...
Randy Morin
randymorin Offline Send Email
Feb 17, 2006
7:08 pm

... Thank you, Randy - I don't necessarily believe that, but I'm still flattered by it :) Nick...
Nick Bradbury
bradbury_sof... Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2006
1:40 am

... The answer depends on how you feel about resolving the unknowable question of whether RSS, as specified in RSS 2.0.1-rv-6, allows HTML markup in elements...
rcade Offline Send Email Feb 17, 2006
8:30 pm

Well, let me just reiterate that if the board intends solely to clarify the spec, I'll toss roses your way. Unresolved issues such as whether markup is...
Nick Bradbury
bradbury_sof... Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2006
1:30 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2010 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines NEW - Help