Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
rss-public
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Message search is now enhanced, find messages faster. Take it for a spin.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
RSS Mime Type Obstacle   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #589 of 1975 |
I'm reading the RFCs related to MIME types and the process to apply
for one.

My read of Section 2.2.4 of RFC 2048 would exclude a joint application
for "application/rss+xml" by the RSS Advisory Board and RSS-DEV
Working Group (or any other shared type).

The section:

"2.2.4. Canonicalization and Format Requirements

"All registered media types must employ a single, canonical data
format, regardless of registration tree.

"A precise and openly available specification of the format of each
media type is required for all types registered in the IETF tree and
must at a minimum be referenced by, if it isn't actually included in,
the media type registration proposal itself."

ftp://ftp.isi.edu/in-notes/rfc2048.txt

Does anyone else have a different take on this?






Wed Apr 5, 2006 3:07 pm

rcade
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #589 of 1975 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

I'm reading the RFCs related to MIME types and the process to apply for one. My read of Section 2.2.4 of RFC 2048 would exclude a joint application for...
rcade
Offline Send Email
Apr 5, 2006
3:08 pm

... RFC 2048 has been obsoleted by RFC 4288 btw. -- Dave...
David Powell
djpowell.geo
Offline Send Email
Apr 5, 2006
5:26 pm

For what it's worth, perhaps RSS 1.0 should register for application/rss+rdf+xml, as has been suggested in a couple of different places: ...
Sean Lyndersay
seanlyndersay
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
7:07 am

Hello Sean, (Sorry for getting off topic everyone.) Just to chime in (because you quoted something I wrote...). (I haven't gotten around to reposting this...
Charles Iliya Krempeaux
supercanadian@...
Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
7:39 am

I appreciate the intention of the "media" parameter. I would recommend using multiple "enclosure-type" parameters that list the MIME types of the enclosures....
ecomputerd
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
10:08 am

Hello, (First, just to say it explicitly, this media="tv" proposal does NOT take into account "mixed" feeds. However, I still believe this to be very useful....
Charles Iliya Krempeaux
supercanadian@...
Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
4:40 pm

Charles, Thank you for this discussion! I'm not arguing against the "hinting", I'm arguing for a different form of the hinting (and one that is consistent with...
ecomputerd
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
7:43 pm

Below is a stab at the application for the media type application/rss+xml. The formatting of Yahoo! Group postings is horrible. I'm open to suggestions on how...
ecomputerd
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
10:30 am

... Disagree. Noone will deny that HTTP / MIME / XML is a tangled mess, but it strikes me as less than wise to willfully make it even worse by having specs...
A. Pagaltzis
a22pag
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
1:36 pm

... How about a simple statement that the charset parameter, if present, MUST agree with the encoding that would be determined by following the rules in...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
1:54 pm

... present, ... the ... Sam, What is the relationship between RFC3023 and the XML 1.0 specification (third edition)? RFC3023 does make frequent reference to...
ecomputerd
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
12:15 am

... Forgive me for the significant snippage, but that's actually the best place to start: real data. The following is slightly dated, but I don't believe that...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
1:18 am

... storage ... are ... any ... the ... documented ... best ... don't ... Sam, I don't mind the significant snippage at all. You reposted and responded to what...
ecomputerd
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
1:58 am

... libxml2 will soon. http://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=331266 http://www.mail-archive.com/xml@.../msg02264.html Regards, -- Aristotle Pagaltzis...
A. Pagaltzis
a22pag
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
4:04 am

... Mine does. I don't actually use it because I'm still not sure how best to handle this, but the option is there. ... Yeah. That's exactly why I haven't done...
James Holderness
james_holder...
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
2:58 am

... Nearly all take efforts to accept XML that is not well formed due to character encoding issues. How far to go is often a matter of judgment and is a...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
12:21 pm

... It could be argued that their courageous stand was more a case of being too lazy to modify their XML parser to be fault tolerant. And their wimping out on...
James Holderness
james_holder...
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
2:35 pm

... "lazy", "courageous", and "wimped out" are all loaded terms. I still feel that rejecting feeds that aren't (locally) well formed is a gutsy and welcome...
Sam Ruby
sa3ruby
Offline Send Email
Apr 7, 2006
3:58 pm

... True. And my suggestions were really only half serious. I just thought your post was in need of an opposing viewpoint on this issue. I find it difficult to...
James Holderness
james_holder...
Offline Send Email
Apr 8, 2006
1:14 am

... I don't think it was pure laziness. I think they found that only a very minimal number of feeds is actually malformed once you get past encoding problems...
A. Pagaltzis
a22pag
Offline Send Email
Apr 8, 2006
8:35 am

... I've only seen the one article in the Google Reader Blog [1], in which they claim about seven percent of all feeds have XML errors. I could be mistaken, ...
James Holderness
james_holder...
Offline Send Email
Apr 8, 2006
2:59 pm

No, let's not make it any more confusing that it needs to be. -Bill Kearney Syndic8.com ... For what it's worth, perhaps RSS 1.0 should register for ...
Bill Kearney
wkearney99
Offline Send Email
Apr 6, 2006
12:25 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help