Agreed. I have generally always thought of SOA being based on a n-tier architecture. When they say 3-tier they are probably referring to the introduction of...
Building applications using object-oriented implies, separate of concerns which is major feature of 3 -tier architecture. Using services doesn't imply ignoring...
I think there's a more subtle point in here: 3-tier or n-tier application architecture is just that -- an *application* architecture. It's focus is on building...
... There are some of us still out here, Gregg. When customers find that WS-* is really the WS-Death*, we're putting the crash test dummies back together...
Happy New Year! If Eric means, SOA and 3-Tier concepts have nothing to do with each other, I agree on the orthogonal orientation of both. "In fact SOA is a...
Michael, I highly recommend Burton Group's Catalyst conference: - San Diego: 23-27 June - Prague: 20-23 October See http://www.catalyst.burtongroup.com/ ...
Well said, Anne, and I think you complied with my 5000-word requirement according to Jeff. :) I worked with an EA once who did equate SOA to a migration from...
... Ok, not to sound like a RESTafarian here (er, don't look at my .sig :) but since REST deals extremly well with scalability and routing, are you referring...
... In this particular case we had to minimize the number of network hops in the chain and provide shared state for stateless services. A JavaSpace mediated...
I'd also like to suggest the next OASIS event, 'Open Standards 2008-Composability within SOA,' http://events.oasis-open.org/home/symposium/2008/ in Santa...
Given the following quote from "Introduction to Service-Oriented Architecture" written by Natis and Schulte in 2003, I'd say it's not only a stretch but...
Rob, I agree that service orientation can be applied at any level, but "service-oriented architecture" is service orientation applied at the enterprise...
I hate adding new terms, but I think we're hurting ourselves by constantly overloading the term SOA. IMHO, we would be better off if we formalized the "The...
... Ok, but where's the connection to REST? Network hops and state issues are more common in SOA that about a RESTful interface, and are generic design issues....
Anne: We simply do not agree on the level that SOA applies to. Indeed, I don't think SOA as an independent "thing" should exist at all. My view is that service...
Why not go the one extra step and just use "The Balanced Views of Architecture?" -Rob ... architecture@yahoogroups.com, "jeffrschneider" <jeffrschneider@...> ...
<< IBM WebSphere CTO Jerry Cuomo sees complex event processing (CEP) becoming the next big thing service-oriented architecture (SOA). He sees this trend...
No need for apologies. Your comment has given me my first blog topic for the year which I will post tonight. :) Regarding SOA at the enterprise level, there is...
My response: http://apsblog.burtongroup.com/2008/01/a-proposed-taxo.html I like your taxonomy, but I see the views as different aspects of the service...
+1! ... -- Nick Gall Phone: +1.781.608.5871 AOL IM: Nicholas Gall Yahoo IM: nick_gall_1117 MSN IM: (same as email) Google Talk: (same as email) Email:...
"complex event processing (CEP) becoming the next big thing service- oriented architecture (SOA)." This sort of statement gives me the heebies. Service...
CALL FOR WORKSHOP PROPOSALS IEEE Joint Conference on E-Commerce Technology (CEC'08) and Enterprise Computing, E-Commerce and E-Services (EEE '08) July 21-24,...
Its back to "Big/Business SOA" v Flog-me-a-product SOA. CEP/EDA/JMS/EJB as the "next" thing in SOA are all about a vendor's own jaundiced view of what they...
... This comment represents one of the things that I find most often in conversations about Jini. The supposition is that an underlying transport/application...
... My particular point is that the problems we encountered with this problem domain were related to "generic design issues" that are not present with Jini but...
Hello, We have two events coming up that would be ofrleveance to some of you. www.dqasiapacific.com and www.kmaustralia.com DQ Asia Pacific 2008 Aligning...
Architecture style? so a style not architecture itself? SOA is not an "A" but a "S" so it is SOS not SOA? Or more appropriately, it is SOS of an Architecture....
There's an interesting recent paper on this topic, published by a group of graduate students (?) at the Large Scale Distributed Information Systems (LSDIS) Lab...