Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
wmlprogramming · WML,XHTML,WURFL & Mobile-related stuff
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Making Google Mobile Search Work for Your Site   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #26163 of 31836 |

People, AdMob just posted an article on their blog which has enough
importance and technical wisdom to be posted here:

http://admob.blogspot.com/2007/11/making-google-mobile-search-work-for.html

enjoy

Luca

========================

Making Google Mobile Search Work for Your Site


Google has made changes to their mobile search. Although many of the
improvements are laudable, it also has created some difficulities for
mobile specific sites. Users now see both mobile web and desktop web
results when searching using their mobile device, all within the same set
of search results. Google identifies sites it thinks are intended for
desktop viewing and sends those URLs through the Google Wireless
Transcoder (GWT) to transcode them for mobile, rather than linking
directly to the website. Examples of transcoded desktop sites can be seen
by searching in http://www.google.com/m. The transcoded sites can be
identified by looking at the link URL, as they are prefixed with
http://www.google.com/gwt/n? .

This can result in these difficulties for mobile site owners:

- If your site has both a desktop representation and a mobile
representation, you would want Google to rank the mobile representation
higher than the transcoded desktop representation in mobile search
results. This is not always the case. Users may be directed to the
transcoded version of your desktop site, which may not provide the user
experience you intended.

- Sometimes Google will mistakenly think your mobile site is intended for
desktop use, and will send your mobile site through the GWT. Given that
your mobile site is already designed for mobile use, this may negatively
impact the user experience and potentially break functionality such as
targeting or billing using the phone's User-Agent or IP address.

Understandably, many in the mobile web community are concerned about the
impact of Google's practice of transcoding desktop sites*. Fortunately,
there is a simple fix to make Google mobile search work for you. I think
it is useful to share this with everyone who operates a mobile site. Here
is the recipe:

Put this tag in the <head> section of all the pages in your site, whether
intended for desktop use or mobile:

<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" media="handheld"
href="http://example.mobi/" title="Mobile/PDA" />

replace http://example.mobi/ with your page’s URL. When you have both a
desktop and mobile version of your site, using the mobile URL tells the
Google Wireless Transcoder to redirect the user to the mobile version.

Let me illustrate this with an example. Our site, TapTap , has implemented
the link tag. When you search for "TapTap" on http://www.google.com/m ,
you will see several results. At the time of writing, the first result
goes to http://taptap.net/ , the desktop web version of our home page,
sent through the GWT. By putting the link tag in our desktop page, we are
able to send users on the phone to our mobile version at
http://m.taptap.net/ , instead of having Google transcode our desktop
page, which are less useful for users on the phone.

Lower in the search results, you can see our mobile site. Unfortunately,
Google misidentifies our mobile site as being for desktop use and sends it
through the GWT http://www.google.com/gwt/n?u=http%3A%2F%2Fm.taptap.net%2F
. By implementing the link tag in our mobile page at http://m.taptap.net/
, we are able to tell the GWT not to transcode the page, sending users
directly to http://m.taptap.net/ as desired.

Note that this may not alter the ranking of your site in Google's index.
This is simply a way to tell the GWT to send the user directly to your
mobile content, regardless of your ranking.

What to put in the href is also important. If possible, you should put the
URL of the mobile equivalent of the current page, or put the URL of the
current page if the page is designed for mobile. If you always put the
front page of your mobile site in the link tag, it may prevent users from
reaching their desired page directly from the Google search results.

We hope this is useful for you.

* Nadir Garouche from SEO Principle has a detailed blog post about
Google's decision here . Dennis from WAP Review has also chimed in . There
are some reports of difficulties in various mailing lists, such as this
one .

=========================

Luca





Thu Nov 29, 2007 9:18 pm

luca_passani
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #26163 of 31836 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

People, AdMob just posted an article on their blog which has enough importance and technical wisdom to be posted here: ...
passani@...
luca_passani
Offline Send Email
Nov 29, 2007
9:19 pm

... I certainly do not want to diminish the value of this article and I think it does a very good job at describing the problem and the solution for anyone...
Andrea Trasatti
mith_y
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2008
5:45 pm

Andrea, When I wrote the blog post I wasn't aware of your post. Yes you are effectively saying the same thing. And there are probably other posts describing...
Nigel Choi
nigelchoi
Offline Send Email
Jan 13, 2008
11:13 pm

Guys, all these techniques sound fine when referring to "semi-static" content (i.e. menus, articles, and such) but how do you apply them for real dynamic...
Jose Alberto Fernandez
j_a_fernandez
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2008
12:20 pm

Jose, Your concern is absolutely valid, but the posts specifically talks about Google's Web Transcoder. Yes how I wish the carrier transcoders will just get...
Nigel Choi
nigelchoi
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2008
5:45 pm

Nigel, There was nothing wrong with your article. Actually you are explaining what can be done today. What I would wish is for Transcoders either operator's or...
Jose Alberto Fernandez
j_a_fernandez
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2008
11:40 am

There are mentions of using POWDER from W3C, a generalized robots.txt- like specification for use in the mobile context just like you said. But for it to...
Nigel Choi
nigelchoi
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2008
5:41 pm

Nigel, As always W3C tries to use an elephant to move a chair. Do we really need an inference engine with attributions of who said what for the purpose? I do...
Jose Alberto Fernandez
j_a_fernandez
Offline Send Email
Jan 15, 2008
6:45 pm

Hi, As Nigel said, POWDER is for general statements about Web resources. One of the use cases is the robots.txt, but not the only. So nobody is using an...
José Manuel Canter...
jmcf@...
Send Email
Jan 16, 2008
7:53 am

Guys, All my comments should be taken in the context of: How to tell transforming gateways or engines where they are allowed to act and where they are not. ...
Jose Alberto Fernandez
j_a_fernandez
Offline Send Email
Jan 16, 2008
2:03 pm

... Agreed, I just wonder why would Google go out and say "we do our best to detect mobile sites, but that's not good enough". I mean, they do their best and I...
Andrea Trasatti
mith_y
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2008
7:17 pm

... All these will help. In all fairness, it's sometimes hard for a machine to tell whether a page is mobile or not without the DTD, Content-Type, and other...
Nigel Choi
nigelchoi
Offline Send Email
Jan 14, 2008
8:44 pm

Hi, ... This is something the W3C Mobile Web Best Practices Working Group is actively working on in its Content Transformations Task Force: ...
Dominique Hazael-Mass...
nimbustier
Offline Send Email
Jan 16, 2008
6:08 pm

It looks like there are updates in the mobile search from Google and maybe this could be a step in the right direction to get mobile sites first when you're...
Andrea Trasatti
mith_y
Offline Send Email
Jan 27, 2008
6:23 pm

Hi Andrea et al, Although a "step in the right direction" we've noticed that Google in some cases is transcoding the page returned by the mobile site. In our...
sbarriba
Offline Send Email
Jan 30, 2008
8:32 am

Shaun, We have heard reports of similar problems and we have experienced it ourselves. You can place a <link> tag in your mobile/Bango page to tell Google to...
Nigel Choi
nigelchoi
Offline Send Email
Jan 30, 2008
4:30 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help